Paul Cook calls for more clarity and consistency after Chesterfield's successful appeal against Kyle McFadzean red card
Manager Paul Cook wants to see more clarity over the laws of the game after Chesterfield successfully appealed a red card.
Kyle McFadzean’s was sent off in the recent draw at Fleetwood after he was initially deemed to have denied Town’s Ronan Coughlan a goal-scoring opportunity.
The Spireites believed it was a wrong call and the authorities agreed, making McFadzean available again for the climax to the season.
While justice was done, Cook acknowledged the increasingly difficult job referees face in the modern game.


"He (Kyle McFadzean) shouldn’t have been sent off but it’s an ongoing thing in football,” he told the Derbyshire Times.
"We’ve got to be careful with referees because I believe we have always played football in an environment where referees are humans and they make mistakes.
"Since the introduction of VAR and the other stuff we are still getting errors so it just makes stuff more contentious.
"A lot of us now don’t know what a penalty is or what offside is or what a goal is. It is something they need to look at maybe in the off season and try to clear up because referees are making big decisions and a lot of them are being wrong.


"I don’t think for one minute that they’re doing it for any other particular reason that they believe it’s the right decision. Maybe this requires better education, I don’t know. But it has to improve a little bit for the game to go forward.
"You have to live with the belief these things balance themselves out. I’m not sure they have for us this season, that’s for sure."
VAR remains confined to the Premier League in England, sparing the lower divisions of the interruptions and long delays which has plagued its operation in the top flight.
Given its problems, there has been no clamour for it to be introduced lower down.
Added Cook: “Forgive me if I’m wrong, because I’m not as intelligent as people making the rules, but I thought VAR was brought in to take away human error, and it hasn’t.
"You could simplify it in terms of a goal’s a goal if it’s over the line, I think if they got that one off to a tee, and maybe the offside one.
"Some of the penalty decisions are ridiculous, aren’t they. One minute if it hits someone’s body it’s a pen. Then the other week in Paris, for example – and I’m a Liverpool fan – (Ibrahima) Konate’s foul wasn’t a pen. I think it was to be honest.
"People should relax on referees. It can’t be a witch hunt against officials. We just want to see more consistency and clarity in the game.”