“We strongly recommend that residents make their views known.” Derbyshire town council sets out opposition to affordable homes proposal

“We strongly recommend that residents make their views known.”

Darley Dale Town Council has called on residents to submit objections against a proposal 58 affordable homes on a greenfield site, saying local water infrastructure is already beyond capacity and pouring sewage into the River Derwent.

As previously reported, WildRose Developments is seeking permission from Derbyshire Dales District Council (DDDC) for its construction plans on a site off Old Road.

Company bosses Andrew Rouse and Jonathan Wildgoose have been seeking to win over residents too, hosting a drop-in event at the Whitworth on Wednesday, November 18, to answer questions and share details on the scheme’s layout, sustainability and impact on the landscape and other environmental factors.

The town council planning committee chairman David Chapman said: “Whilst having no objection to applications in suitable locations, and understanding the need for affordable housing in Darley Dale, the town council planning committee felt that all the harm issues mentioned by the appeal Inspector in 2017 remain and that new, other issues that carry similar planning weight are now present.

“As a result we felt that the harm outweighs the benefit and recommended refusal. The committee strongly recommends that residents make their views known, for or against the proposal, by posting on the district council planning portal at derbyshiredales.gov.uk with the application reference 26/01064/FUL.”

The proposed layout of the development.placeholder image
The proposed layout of the development. | Contributed

In 2016, the district council rejected plans from Mr Wildgoose’s previous company - the since dissolved Wildgoose Construction - to build 60 homes on the same site. The following year, a Government planning inspector rejecting an appeal against that decision.

Those rejections hinged on a lack of sustainability considerations and a harm to the openness of the area, closing the current gap between Darley Dale and north-west Matlock and thereby eliminating Darley’s village character.

But with increased housebuilding targets handed down to the district by central Government, and a pressing need for affordable homes across the Dales, the application will be looked at in a fresh light.

Set against those pressures though, are the ongoing concerns about Severn Trent Water’s (STW) management of, and investment in, infrastructure serving Darley.

The Environment Agency placed a statutory improvement action in 2024 on STW to dramatically reduce the spills of untreated sewage into the River Derwent by 2030.

That came after STW continually reported ‘hydraulic capacity’ as the cause of increasing numbers of spills since 2020.

According to official figures, the overflow supporting Darley Dale - known as CSO11, opposite the Arc Leisure Centre - has spilled diluted raw sewage into the River Derwent about 90 times a year on average since monitoring began in 2019.

The Environment Agency’s target is around 40 and the government’s target for 2050 is no more than 10 a year.

So far this year, it is though that overflows from CSO11 have passed 900 hours, the majority in January and February and likely to be repeated as winter sets in.

The town’s planning committee has therefore concluded that adding new properties to an already ‘at capacity’ sewer will only exacerbate the situation.

Weighing in favour of that view, DDDC’s infrastructure delivery plan, published in July this year, states: “There is a need to divert development away from combined sewers where there are known capacity issues. The developer’s ‘right to connect’ to the sewage network ... can make this more challenging.”

A Severn Trent spokesperson said: “We’re investing £2billion to improve the health of rivers and reduce spills which fell by 41 per cent across the region in 2025, albeit a drier year.

“In the Matlock and Darley Dale areas, we’re spending £20million to upgrade Lea Sewage Treatment Works, including boosting capacity and reducing phosphorous in the treatment process – helping improve the health of the River Derwent.

“We are also installing a new storm storage tank in Matlock as part of our spills reduction programme, which has seen 3,000 improvements and interventions completed so far.”

For their part, WildRose does not disagree with the capacity argument, but insists the relevant authorities have a responsibility to ensure adequate infrastructure is available to a growing population.

Mr Wildgoose said: “Derbyshire Dales District Council working alongside Severn Trent Water have a responsibility to provide the infrastructure. The infrastructure currently in place is sub par and we believe the community of Darley Dale deserve these issues to be resolved, regardless of any new development.

“It is the responsibility of STW to deliver infrastructure and not use their failure to frustrate sustainable development which is desperately needed and clearly within the explicit intention of the government's National Planning Policy Framework.

“Darley Dale Town Council have expressed concerns relating to the drainage issues on recent developments in the settlement. We believe these issues are most likely the result of poor design or construction of those privately owned systems.”

He added: “It is perhaps worth noting that neither Severn Trent Water nor the Environment Agency have raised any objection acknowledging that the site has never been recorded as flooding, is located in flood zone one and the design of our proposed sustainable drainage system will reduce flood risk.”

In the meantime, Mr Wildgoose is keen to emphasise arguments in favour of the development.

He said: “WildRose are proud to be promoting the Old Road site and feels it is important to explain why. Satisfying the unmet housing need in Darley Dale is a significant benefit for the community and is important in planning terms. The site is in a sustainable location and the council has a duty to provide housing to meet local needs and the infrastructure to support that development.

“The housing need in Darley Dale is defined by DDDC records as: 217 households on the Housing Register looking for Affordable Homes and specifically there are 65 households living in unsuitable accommodation in Darley Dale itself. This housing need is currently only being partially met by permissioned sites in the settlement.

“This development will include 15 shared ownership homes, allowing young people to get on the home ownership ladder. The demographic data and forecast primary school numbers both demonstrate Darley Dale has an aging population and a declining school pupil population which does not encourage a flourishing community.”

He added: “This is a sustainable location for development because it is on the A6 next to bus stops with direct routes to Bakewell, Matlock and beyond including Highfields School. We are also within easy walking distance of the primary school, medical centre, shops, cafes and parks in the centre of Darley Dale. It is close to the heart of Darley Dale and as such will play an important role in strengthening that community.”

He also hopes that the reasons for the 2016 rejection will now be set aside, saying: “The site has a low ecological and biodiversity value because it is merely modified grass land bordered by two busy roads, housing, one field and a factory.

“There is no longer a significant adverse visual impact because the site is screened by housing and trees. It will be seen from the roads in close proximity and mostly glimpses from the surrounding predominantly distant hillside locations.

“The site sits in the local PD10 policy area designed to maintain the green gaps on the A6 corridor. The fields next door to the site around the Warney Brook will still maintain this.

“However the importance of this policy is diminished in the National Planning Policy Framework due to limited local designation only, while the provision of affordable housing against unmet need is regarded as urgent and of significant benefit to be weighed in the planning balance.”

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice