Villagers sceptical over all-affordable Derbyshire homes scheme

Villagers are sceptical of plans to build nearly 100 affordable homes in their area after the same developer twice successfully petitioned to build fewer cut-price houses.

Derby-based firm Wheeldon Brothers has asked Amber Valley Borough Council to change a planning approval it was formally granted in September 2020 to build 93 homes off Hall Road and Plumptre Road, Langley Mill.

Protesting residents in Hall Road, Langley Mill.placeholder image
Protesting residents in Hall Road, Langley Mill.

The change it has asked for is to alter the scheme to a fully affordable project, including different numbers of each size of home.

Residents claim the homes themselves are also to decrease in size if the change is approved.

An aerial view of the proposed 93-home site.placeholder image
An aerial view of the proposed 93-home site.

When councillors had granted permission for the scheme six years ago, the 93-home application was to include 27 affordable homes, just shy of the 30 per cent expected.

However, in 2022, Wheeldon asked for this to be reduced to 14 affordable homes due to the cost of the scheme, including contamination remediation costs.

In early 2025 it asked the council to reduce this to no affordable housing, again citing financial viability, and was given permission to reduce it to eight instead.

This is why when an application was submitted in September to change the development to 93 affordable homes – 45 per cent shared ownership and 55 per cent social rent – residents were more than a little confused.

Villagers say long-term flooding, greenfield development, contamination and highways safety remain strong and are key reasons as to why the development should never go ahead.

A number of campaigners are calling for the borough council to ask for a new planning application, due to the changes proposed.

This includes increasing the number of two-bed homes and three-bed homes and reduction in four-bed homes, to an overall makeup of four one-bed, 43 two-bed, 34 three-bed and 12 four-bed.

Meanwhile, the new request confirms that Wheeldon Brothers claims it did make a start on the development within three years of permission – meaning it has not lapsed – saying it had demolished a building on the plot just 74 days from the three-year deadline in June 2023.

Graeme Pope, who has lived opposite the site for three years, said: “This is one of few meadows on a flood plain that has never been ploughed. It should be cherished and protected, not dug up and covered with concrete and tarmac. This field is home to many species and I feel blessed to be able to watch them change and grow.”

Sheena Trower, who has lived in the village for more than 30 years, said two-thirds of the site remains greenfield and within a floodzone and ought not be developed, “whatever guise is used to present it as suitable”.

Fellow resident Shaun Pearson said: “Every time we have a period of prolonged or heavy rain I watch the water level creeping up the fields toward our houses.

“If this development goes ahead, and the floodplain is gone, that water has to go somewhere. Soon, no one in Langley Mill will be able to get insurance as the weather gets more extreme and flooding goes from once in a lifetime to once a year.”

Councillor Amanda Paget, a borough councillor, said: “Affordable housing must be about providing good-quality homes that people can genuinely live comfortably in, not simply increasing housing numbers.

“I’d love to see more suitable, good-quality housing for social rent, ensuring we meet local needs without compromising on residents’ quality of life or safety.”

Bob Woollard, Wheeldon Brothers director, in a letter to the council, said: “This revised scheme offers a substantial public benefit in addition to the delivery of the already approved 93 homes.

“It provides an efficient and deliverable means of bringing forward a wholly affordable scheme on a site where the principle, housing number and broad development strategy are already established.

“The application should be determined positively and without unnecessary procedural duplication so that this delivery opportunity is not delayed and can contribute to the current five-year housing land supply.

“Importantly, this is not a speculative amendment to an unimplemented permission. Wheeldon Brothers is the identified housebuilder and is ready to take the development forward, with Places for People in place as the registered provider for the affordable homes. “The revised house types and layout have been developed specifically to support that delivery model.

“The proposal therefore provides a clear, active and deliverable route to implementation of the scheme quickly.”

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice