Derbyshire council wins six-year court battle over woman’s unauthorised home in a barn
“There are serious consequences around ignoring planning rules.”
Derbyshire Dales District Council has won a six-year planning battle after a Darley Dale woman finally complied with an order to remove an unauthorised dwelling concealed inside an agricultural barn.
At Nottingham County Court on Monday, November 16, Judge Jonathan Owen, accepted photographic evidence submitted by Helen Lowe, of North Park Farm, Whitworth Road, that she had removed a domestic fireplace - the last step in complying with an enforcement notice issued by the council in February 2020 and subsequent Planning Inspectorate and court orders.
A spokesperson for DDDC said: "The judge acknowledged in his summing up that the district council had acted very reasonably in this matter and was correct to bring it to court. Once again, the court awarded costs against Miss Lowe.
"We are pleased and somewhat relieved that this protracted process is now at an end, and we are grateful also to the Darley Dale community for their patience as we pursued this complex and lengthy court action.”
As previously reported, at a sentencing hearing adjourned in August this year, the judge had warned Miss Lowe that failure to completely remove the remainder of the unauthorised dwelling could result in an imprisonment term that would unlikely be less than two months. At that hearing, court costs of £1,144 were awarded against Miss Lowe.
In May, the council had secured a successful contempt of court ruling against Miss Lowe and the council was also awarded £10,000 in court costs on that occasion.
The court heard how Miss Lowe constructed a residential dwelling within an agricultural building without planning permission, and that the structure was deliberately concealed to avoid detection.
In quotes published by the Daily Mail in June 2026, Miss Lowe said: “'It's a temporary building to look after my sheep when they're lambing. It's not Windsor Castle.
“It's just got facilities in it, a bed, windows. The council says it was concealed - but it wasn't concealed at all.
“It was only built because I needed facilities here, and then during Covid I ended up staying longer.”
The structure was said to include windows, doors, insulation, floorboards, kitchen units, much of built it using recycled, reclaimed or surplus materials.
Following reports of a potential breach of planning laws, council officers carried out a detailed investigation and served an enforcement notice in February 2020.
Miss Lowe appealed to the Government’s Planning Inspectorate, but the appeal was dismissed on in February 2022.
The inspector required her to cease using the building as a dwelling, remove the unauthorised structure and demolish an unlawful extension to the barn. Miss Lowe failed to comply within the time allowed.
The council subsequently took Miss Lowe to court, and in September 2024 Miss Lowe was ordered to remove the unauthorised dwelling and cease living in the barn.
Despite this, she continued to occupy the building and did not carry out the required works.
After further non‑compliance, in July 2025 the council applied for contempt of court proceedings, leading to the trial in May where Miss Lowe was found in contempt of court for failing to comply with the court’s order.
The DDDC spokesman said: "We want to stress again that there are serious consequences around ignoring planning rules and failing to get the correct permission before carrying out development.
“The planning system only works when everyone follows the same rules. It is not acceptable for a few people to disregard the process while most comply.”