Derbyshire council to keep waste centre open after new evidence and thousands of concerns
Derbyshire County Council’s Reform UK Leader has told how a fresh move to keep a waste centre open despite it previously being earmarked for possible closure was based on significant evidence from one of his own councillors who was determined to save the tip.
Council Leader, Cllr Alan Graves, also welcomed and fully considered over 6,500 submitted comments from residents on the council’s plans with nearly 94per cent opposed to the closure of Glossop Household Waste Recycling Centre while the council considered the site’s future in a bid to save money.
The Reform UK-controlled council also faced a campaign from Labour’s High Peak MP Jon Pearce and Cllr Damien Greenhalgh who submitted a 4,400-plus signature petition to save the site on Melandra Road.
They have since accused the council of reversing its plans after it revealed that its Cabinet is expected to agree at a meeting, on November 26, to keep the site open.


Cllr Graves said: “It bothers me not one bit that the opposition parties claim this is a u-turn.
“What I care about is getting the decision right for the people of Derbyshire. It does not matter how they frame it because in this council it is about making the right decision.”
Conservative, Green, Labour and Liberal Democrat councillors, as well as Reform Cllr Jason Isherwood, opposed the site’s closure after questioning evidence with concerns that a closure would leave residents having to travel to the High Peak’s other waste site at Waterswallows, in Buxton.
Mr Pearce and opposition councillors also raised concerns any proposed closure would place pressure on other waste sites and could trigger an increase in fly-tipping with more waste enforcement problems.


Cllr Graves explained the site’s future was considered to save £360,000 but he claims the move to keep the tip open was swayed by Reform UK Cllr Jason Isherwood’s hard work, research and fresh evidence alongside residents’ concerns.
He added that after Cllr Isherwood and others questioned the reliability of previous evidence and its source concerning the site’s usage, the council re-examined the situation leading to a move to keep the site up-and-running.
Cllr Graves added: “It was always an option to keep the site open. Cllr Isherwood was vehemently opposed to closing the site and he came to talk to me about how he got the evidence and we could see it was not doing as poorly as was first thought.
“I said if you want this situation to change you need to find the information that is important and he did it and it’s a big credit to him.
“He amassed evidence and got people talking and even though Jon Pearce and Cllr Greenhalgh were attacking the council with a petition, not one of them came to me about it. I am really pleased we are going to keep it open.”
The council considered the closure among budget saving plans, and it initially argued the centre collected the lowest volume of waste out of all the council’s nine waste sites and it was the least used with 65,700 visits a year compared to more than a million across all of its sites.
It also estimated that around seven out of ten visitors who use the centre live outside of the county and it claimed a £500,000 investment would be needed to make sure the site complies with modern requirements and safety regulations.
The council also argued most Derbyshire districts and boroughs operate with one waste site and the High Peak currently has two includingGlossop and one in Buxton.
But a review of the site’s Automatic Number Plate Recognition system registering use by local residents alongside looking at how the site could be operated more efficiently helped to establish a more favourable position concerning usage which allowed the council to consider keeping it open.
Cllr Graves said: “The fact people engaged really helps. At the end of the day I believe we are here for the people we represent and that is a compelling argument and, obviously, we got correct information about people using the site that was presented to us and we made positive changes. I am really pleased we are going to keep it open.”
The council has identified measures to off-set the centre’s operating costs including enforcing a residents-only scheme preventing the site from being used by people living outside Derbyshire.
Savings are also expected on waste disposal costs following High Peak Borough Council’s new household food waste collection system which involves composting food waste reducing the county council’s disposal costs.
Cllr Graves added that to get the best value for Derbyshire taxpayers it was absolutely right to have considered closing the tip.
Mr Pearce said: “I’m absolutely delighted that Glossop tip has been saved. This is a fantastic result for our community and a reminder of what can happen when local people come together and make their voices heard.
“Throughout this campaign, I have been clear that closing Glossop tip was the wrong decision.
“It would have left residents facing longer journeys to dispose of their waste, placed greater pressure on other recycling centres and risked making fly-tipping an even bigger problem. Reform have now had to listen and reverse their plans.”
Cllr Greenhalgh, who represents Glossop South, said they challenged Reform’s figures, questioned their arguments, and kept up the pressure, and with 94per cent of the consultation opposing a closure, and with thousands signing a petition, the council could not ignore the strength of feeling.