Chesterfield councillor to decide on proposed sale of ‘much-loved’ play area
Concerned Chesterfield residents who have urged their borough council to revamp and save a play area instead of selling the land have been told that a Cabinet Member will be expected to make the final decision.
The Labour-led council’s plan to sell the temporarily closed play area, The Pen, at Stone Lane and High Street, in New Whittington, Chesterfield, has been met with opposition and concerns from campaigning resident Tracy Poole and Liberal Democrat Cllrs Barry Bingham and Paul Holmes as well from over 120 residents on an Action Group Facebook page.
Cllr Holmes revealed he has been told a decision on whether to sell the land or not will be taken under delegated powers by a Cabinet Member from the controlling authority’s Labour administration after a public consultation was overseen by the council’s legal and estates team.
He said: “I was told by a senior officer on Friday afternoon (November 13) that following the consultation officers were drawing up recommendations which would then be decided under delegated powers.”


Cllr Holmes explained just one Labour councillor will take the decision after considering recommendations from council officers, and locally elected councillors and residents will only be told of the decision afterwards.
An Action Group set up by Ms Poole complained to the council withCllrs Bingham and Holmes over the plan after it originally asked for views 19 months ago and the current position only came to light in an advert in the Derbyshire Times and on a notice pinned to a lamppost.
LibDem councillors distributed over two thousand leaflets in the neighbourhood to highlight the situation and to warn people they only had until October 30 to submit further views.
They claim The Pen was well used when it was open and they are concerned any sale could see the loss of nearby trees on High Street.


Cllr Bingham, who oversees New Whittington, andCllr Holmes, who is the council’s Liberal Democrat Group Leader, questioned claims by the council that it would cost £100,000 to bring the play area back into use and make it safe amidst concerns over the unknown ownership of a potentially costly and dangerous nearby boundary wall.
Chesterfield Borough Council originally asked for views in March, 2025, on the proposed sale of The Pen as well as a derelict play area on Holland Road, at Old Whittington, which was replaced with an ‘excellent’ play area nearby, according toCllr Holmes.
The council has stated there are two alternative play areas to The Pen, one atBrearley Park, and one off Devonshire Avenue North and Albert Road.
Ms Poole, who described The Pen as a ‘much-loved’, said: “The Pen was for all children of all ages to play together and importantly to keep an eye on each other offering parents or guardians peace of mind.”
She has urged the council to reopen The Pen because she said it is greatly missed and is a real asset during the winter when children are unable to play at the waterlogged park.
Chesterfield Borough Council stated the authority recognises the importance of play areas and it has invested around £1m to ensure every community has access to a play space.
The council added The Pen has been closed and secured for at least two years because of serious safety concerns around the retaining wall and it is exploring options and considering all comments regarding the future use of the land and a decision to sell has not yet been taken.
Chesterfield Borough Council estimated that it would cost £100,000 to reopen The Pen with essential works to make it safe including replacing the retaining wall, removing vegetation, installing a new surface and new goalposts.
The council stated if the land is deemed to be surplus to requirements, a further report will be developed with options relating to disposal options for the land and this will then be determined by the relevant cabinet member.
Once council officers fully review whether they think the land should be sold their recommendations will be considered by a Cabinet Member who will make the final decision.
A council spokesperson said: “We recognise that some residents and local councillors have strong views about the future of this site and we are now collating the consultation responses to inform a report on this matter.
“Once the report has been completed it will provide recommendations about the future of the site.
“The report will then be considered by the relevant Cabinet Member regarding its future.
“This is a complex process that requires careful consideration and we are ensuring that we follow the relevant procedures and legislation that guide the disposal of council assets.”
It is believed the most likely Cabinet Member to make the final decision will be Deputy Leader,Cllr AmandaSerjeant, who oversees Finance and Asset Management.
Ms Poole thanked those who made submissions and she said she hopes their comments will make the council reconsider the planned sale of The Pen.