'Still looks like one of the club’s better summer signings' - player ratings from Chesterfield 1 Gillingham 1

Manager Paul Cook surprised many by sticking with the starting line-up that dipped at Rotherham United for the midweek tussle with Gillingham.

A few players had a point to prove and did so, the only snag they couldn’t quite put to bed a Gillingham side that closed out a draw with some all-hands-to-the-pumps defence and use of the dark arts.

Liam Mandeville: Derbyshire Times' Man of the Match. Pic by Tina Jennerplaceholder image
Liam Mandeville: Derbyshire Times' Man of the Match. Pic by Tina Jenner

And so to the minefield of the Player Ratings ...

Ryan Boot 6: Didn’t have too much to do shots wise and one miss-timed punch aside, it was another competent shift from the stopper. Would have kept a clean sheet but for a deflection.

Goal scorer Josh Koroma on the attack against Gillinghamplaceholder image
Goal scorer Josh Koroma on the attack against Gillingham

Remeao Hutton 6: Playing against his old club, the full-back’s most prominent work seemed to come came late on when he pushed on and floated in some inviting crosses that begged for a telling touch.

Jack Simpson 6: As at Rotherham on Saturday,another good game but had an involvement in an opposition goal. Still looks like one of the club’s better summer signings.

Kyle McFadzean 6: 40 next year or not, the centre-half was comfortable. Nearly scored with a close-range flick early in the second half.

Lewis Gordon 6: Another solid stint from the trusty left-back and should have hit the target from close in in the first half. Still waiting for his first Chesterfield goal.

Back under the lights at the SMHplaceholder image
Back under the lights at the SMH

Ryan Stirk 7: Ran around, harried opponents, got a foot in. Dirty work aplenty.

George McEachran 6: Better than at Rotherham on Saturday before being subbed late on.

Dilan Markanday 7: Heavily involved in team’s best work in the first half and only a finger-tip save denied him a goal. Just need a bit more end product from all the skill.

Liam Mandeville 8: Here, there and everywhere and did more than most to keep Gillingham under the cosh. Low-down save denied him what would have been a deserved winner.

Josh Koroma 7: Starting place must have been in question after Saturday. Justified Paul Cook’s loyalty with a beautifully taken goal and a shoot-on-sight attitude. Quieter second half, hence the mark.

Lee Bonis 6: Shook off a nasty knock at the weekend to play. Led the line whole-heartedly but the better chances fell to others.

Subs

Louie Marsh (for Koroma 76) 7: On for his debut less than 48 hours after joining. Slipped into little pockets of space and looked decent.

Tom Naylor (for McEachran 76) 6: Not quite as effective as his sub stint on Saturday but his fresh legs helped the cause.

Fraser Bryden (for Bonis) 77) 6: On for Bonis and still adjusting to the cut and thrust of League Two.

Junior Eccleston (for Hutton) 90 N/A

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice