Are Chesterfield a victim of their own success? Small minority of fans are getting fidgety

I have been reporting on Chesterfield for almost seven years and the reaction to Saturday’s defeat took me back to when I first started.

Back then the Spireites were in a really dark place. It was a few games into the second season in the National League and they were really struggling. Promotion was the aim but they were getting turned over by part-time outfits. There was fierce anger towards the then ownership. There was no connection between the fans, players and manager John Sheridan. Social media was toxic. It was horrible.

Thankfully, those days are well in the past and the club is back in the Football League, has good owners, a talented squad of players, has Paul Cook as manager again and are playing in front of big crowds. It is a totally different club from my first day in the job.

But not everyone is happy. There is a minority of fans who, surprisingly to me, wouldn’t mind a change in the dugout. I am not sure if that is what they genuinely want or whether it is just emotions running high after a game. It does only seem to be a small section, but when they are in your mentions and on your timeline after every defeat or draw, it can make it feel like there are a lot of them and that they are getting louder. They are getting a bit fidgety. A bit restless.

Are Chesterfield a victim of their own success?placeholder image
Are Chesterfield a victim of their own success?

The level of anger after losing to bottom club Newport County on Saturday was quite hot. The temperature of frustration had gone up. On one hand, I get it. Chesterfield are underachieving at the moment. It was a really disappointing result. They were wasteful in front of goal and then gifted Newport the lead. On paper, they arguably have the best attacking players in the division. They regularly concede soft goals and, for all the possession they have, they don’t actually create that much. They are all valid grumbles.

But there are counter arguments. They haven’t had Armando Dobra for three months. They had been without Dilan Markanday for eight matches until the weekend. They have had other injuries which have left some areas of the team stretched. They have made seven new signings in this window and they will need time to gel. New partnerships are being formed. I accept that these points can only last for so long before they run out but, in my opinion, they are reasonable ‘excuses’ for at least a few more matches. And let’s not forget that Chesterfield were 13 points off the play-offs after 33 matches last season. They were 16th in March and still got into the play-offs. So it is not impossible to jump from ninth to third.

Is winning promotion this season a case of ‘win or bust’? I don’t think it is. Everyone wants promotion and they are capable of doing it. You look at the teams at the top and think that Chesterfield should be higher and that there is an opportunity to do something here. But the sky is not going to fall in if they are in League Two again next season. I do think not making the play-offs would be a ‘failure’, though.

Perhaps the club has become a victim of its own recent success? Cook’s post-Newport comments, which were along the lines of, ‘let’s not forget where we have come from’ did not wash with some people. Have they already forgotten what it was like to spend six years in non-league? Or are they right? Should they be doing a lot better? I wouldn’t say the fanbase is divided but there are some cracks.

My view? It is not for me to tell people how to feel about their football team. They pay their money and travel across the country in great numbers. I want Chesterfield to do well but I’m not a ‘fan.’ But would it be beneficial to be a bit less reactionary to every result? Will the same ‘Cook out’ accounts be singing ‘Paul Cook’s barmy army’ after a couple of wins? I’ll leave my judgement until the end of the season.

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice