‘It’s a huge problem for our roads’ says locals as Derbyshire sees the highest rise in pothole compensation claims
Derbyshire has seen the highest rise in pothole compensation claims, according to a new study, with the thousands more drivers sending repair bills to the county council
The survery, carried out by motoring group The RAC, found that pothole compensation claims to local authorities across the countyr have risen by an average of 91% from 2021 to 2024
Derbyshire has seen the highest rise in pothole compensation claims, with Glasgow and Oxfordshire being second and third.
In a freedom of information request, the RAC found that the number of claims in Derbyshire annually, has jumped from 224 in 2021, to a staggering 3,307 in 2024.


However, the study also found that only a quarter of claims in 2024, resulted in any payouts.
In Derbyshire, the average amount paid by the council has only risen by £124 over the three years.
RAC head of policy Simon Williams said: “The massive three-year rise in pothole compensation claims made by drivers shows what a huge task it is returning the roads to a respectable standard.
“Drivers are still suffering the consequences of years of neglect to Britain’s local road network. But even if you submit a compensation claim the odds aren’t good, with around 40,000 requests for reimbursement turned down in 2024 alone,” he added.


The Department for Transport said the government was spending £7.3bn over the next four years on improving road surfaces.
However, Derbyshire councillor Charlotte Hill, the council’s cabinet member for potholes, highways and transport, said claims had fallen by 72% since May 2025.
“The backlog of potholes has also been cleared, and the highways service is now prepared to maintain this level through winter,” she said.
“Going forward, Derbyshire highways can become more proactive rather than reactive, and work to make repairs before they become an issue for residents.”


The RAC estimates that that a typical repair bill for a family car with damage worse than a puncture from a pothole is £590.
Debbie Dawson from Eaton Bank, Little Eaton has made a complaint to the council about the potholes on her road.
“I’ve sent photographs of the potholes to Derbyshire County Council and the following week, they were repaired, but it was only temporary and I think a complete overhaul of the road is needed to fully solve it.
“Fortunately they haven’t damaged my car, but I have hit them and worried about it,” she added.
Ford Lane in Allestree is another area which is badly affected.
Allison Butterworth lives on the road: “They’re a big issue especially since the road is so busy, with lots of people taking the shortcut to the A38.
“They’ve been filled up before but they’ve open up again because they’re obviously filled in cheaply and it doesn’t last.”