Green light for controversial plan to sell alcohol at Derbyshire village coffee shop

A tiny Derbyshire village coffee shop will not “become a pub”, its tenants have stressed after controversial plans to sell alcohol were approved.

A South Derbyshire District Council hearing saw councillors back proposals from Find Cafe in Lower Green, Findern, to sell alcohol.

The move followed much controversy in the village, with the plans sparking more than 40 objections from residents – compared to two letters of support for the proposals.

However, despite concerns over noise and disruption, councillors allowed the plans from the diminutive coffee shop, in the former parish rooms, which currently sells hot drinks, juices and healthy breakfast and lunch options.

Find Cafe in Lower Green, Findern.placeholder image
Find Cafe in Lower Green, Findern.

Tenants David Moxon and Tracey Donaldson applied to sell alcohol and host occasional live music performances indoors between noon and 10pm Sunday through Wednesday and between noon and 11pm Thursday through Saturday.

However, councillors approved a change to these hours, allowing music performances indoors from 12.30-10pm Sunday through Wednesday and until 12.30-11pm Thursday through Saturday.

Meanwhile, alcohol can be served from noon until 9pm every day of the week, only in the seating areas outlined on the licence, not taken elsewhere, but cannot be served outside past 9pm and the outdoor area also must be cleared by that time.

The hearing was told that Mr Moxon and Ms Donaldson, who lease the property from the parish council, would only ever look to have around 25 people on the premises.

David Moxon and Tracey Donaldson, tenants of Find Cafe in Lower Green, Findernplaceholder image
David Moxon and Tracey Donaldson, tenants of Find Cafe in Lower Green, Findern

Mr Moxon, a manager for Tesco, said: “We are not looking to fill the venue and it is not going to become a pub. I don’t want it to be a pub. I want it to be a coffee shop.”

He said the alcohol licence would be to facilitate drinks sales during evening pottery classes and to enable the function room to be able to cater for more events.

Ms Donaldson said: “We do not want to become a pub, we have always wanted to run a coffee shop in the community. We have already had approaches for baby showers, afternoon teas and a Christmas gathering and this would give us the flexibility we need.”

Cllr Andy Kirke questioned why a coffee shop would need to open as late as 10.30pm when the tenants have made clear “they do not want to become a pub”.

Mr Moxon said there would be one or two events per week, typically from 7-9pm, with most only in the afternoon.

He said: “We are not going to be hosting 18th birthday parties, that would just cause me all sorts of problems as a designated premises supervisor.”

Cllr Kirke said the tenants could apply for temporary event notices for the extra events they wish to hold, to which the applicants said this would not make them as flexible as required to entertain these offers.

Robert Hudson, a Findern resident, who said he was likely one of the younger retirees in the village, said the venue could present a “genuine disturbance”, impacting people with mental and physical health issues.

He said the venue could “potentially become a drinking den to replace The Wheel pub” – the village’s last pub.

Gillian Winfield said parking issues caused by the venue were already impacting other businesses in the village, saying it was “just not viable”.

Maisie Trotman told the meeting that the venue was intending to sell alcohol for £12 for a bottle of prosecco, which they could take away to consume off the premises.

She said: “What is to stop a group of youths putting their money together and getting a bottle of prosecco?”

Ms Trotman also said opera singers potentially performing in the venue could be disruptive.

Diana Winfield said the application did not match the business it was being paired with.

Adrian Bird claimed the application represented a “classic Trojan horse situation”, in which the business was masquerading as something it is not.

Richard Winfield said the outdoor area, a narrow strip of grass guarded by a low chain fence alongside Lower Green, was unsafe, and said outdoor evening smoking was already an issue.

Emma McHugh, the council’s licensing manager, said the venue’s outdoor grass area was not currently part of the premises licence, so an “off-sales” expansion was required to serve alcohol there, with a separate application needed to add it to the premises without off-sales.

Ms Donaldson said the venue only intended to sell alcohol through off-sales for people to drink on the outdoor part of the premises and said they would gladly accept this restriction in the licence.

Following the hearing, Ms Donaldson said: “We are pleased with the result, it was a balanced outcome for both parties.

“We are citizens in the area and we want to get along with the community, why would you want to upset your neighbours?”

The married couple moved from Solihull to Mickleover and after the tragic passing of both of Ms Donaldson’s parents, solace was sought in the community of a local coffee shop, which inspired her to use her inheritance to open a business in nearby Findern.

She said: “We fell in love with the area and we wanted to replicate that welcoming community feel. We don’t want to be a high street cafe, we want to host community events like book clubs, stitch and share and encourage all artists to get in touch to use the space.”

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice