Council in tug-of-war with developer over affordable homes at new Derbyshire housing site

A Derbyshire council is in a tug-of-war with a developer over affordable homes and other contributions from a pending 187-home plan

David Wilson Homes wants to build 187 homes off Swadlincote Lane, Castle Gresley, stemming from the Cadley Hill/Hearthcote Road roundabout.

However, it said it cannot afford to provide 30 percent affordable housing due to construction and material costs and the price of developing the complex plot.

So, instead of offering 56 affordable homes, it suggested 19 instead (10 per cent).

The green space where 194 homes could be built in Swadlincote Lane, Castle Gresley.placeholder image
The green space where 194 homes could be built in Swadlincote Lane, Castle Gresley.

However, in an apparent war of the viability assessments, the district council said the developer needed to instead find savings of around half a million pounds from the scheme and that it could cater for 25 affordable homes – 13 percent.

Alongside this, the developer had sought to cut costs by not paying for the open space to be maintained by the district council and instead package the land up in a development management company, through which residents would be charged extra for its upkeep.

The council firmly rejected this idea and said it was a responsibility the developer must still fund.

However, it has said the developer can scrap alternative owed mitigations for its scheme, totalling £370,000, namely: £208,816 for outdoor sports improvements, £78,700 for built facilities improvements (such as leisure centres and parks), £69,600 for cemeteries and £13,200 for libraries.

It would still be asked to pay for £702,000 worth of contributions, including: £187,000 for healthcare facility improvements, £147,000 for special educational need improvements, £170,000 for sustainable travel and bus stop improvements, £48,000 for the National Forest and £132,000 for biodiversity conservation.

Council officials, recommending approval of the plans, wrote: “The delivery of housing and affordable housing in this location is afforded significant positive weight in the planning balance. The conclusion of viability appraisals has demonstrated that the site is not capable of delivering a full 30 percent affordable housing units, however given the need for affordable housing development management officers consider the delivery of 25 units.

“Officers have also given consideration to improved and safer connectivity over the A444, but this is not considered necessary to make the development acceptable on planning grounds.

“Having regard for the council’s absence of a five-year housing land supply and the need to deliver both market and affordable dwellings, this site and the proposals within this application are considered to outweigh any harms.”

If approved, it would lead to a 17-acre patch of green land which is now entirely encircled by housing development on three sides, and an industrial estate, filled in.

The plot has been labelled the “last green space” in Castle Gresley.

A total of 36 objection letters have been submitted to the council over the plans citing traffic concerns, impact on wildlife, disturbance during construction and the lack of a bus service and wider infrastructure.

However, several support letters were also submitted, saying the increased access would be beneficial to the wider area including for hedgehogs and to bungalows.

The plan had initially included 194 homes but this was reduced to 187 during the application process.

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice