Reform Derbyshire councillor joins opposition stance against plans to close waste centre
A Reform UK councillor has joined opposition councillors in a united stance against Reform-controlled Derbyshire County Council’s proposal to close a High Peak household waste recycling centre as part of budget saving plans.
The Reform-led council is considering the future of the Glossop Household Waste Recycling Centre, on Melandra Road, to save £360,000 as part of £22.4 million worth of saving plans for the 2026-27 financial year after the authority has argued it is the least used of all its nine tips and the High Peak area already boasts two such sites.
But Reform UK Cllr Jason Isherwood joined Conservative, Green Party, Labour and Liberal Democrat councillors to oppose the plan at a council meeting on February 11 as they raised questions over usage evidence and concerns that residents will have to travel further to the High Peak’s other waste site in Buxton and that the proposed closure may lead to waste enforcement problems.
Conservative Cllr Jean Wharmby, for Glossop North, called on the Reform council with backing from Cllr Isherwood and Conservative, Green, Labour and Lib Dem councillors to keep the service open and use a share of a recent Labour Government funding allocation of £2.6m to help save the site.


Cllr Wharmby said: “£360,000 is a small amount to keep a vital service open and with the £2.6m that was found out about recently I am sure money could be found.”
She added: “It’a big worry to the people of Glossop. I hope people can support this amendment. There is £2.6m in the pot and we cannot get the proper data and a proper review and if we don’t do it now it will come back to council and we will have to have this debate again.”
Cllr Wharmby argued that Glossop has one of the highest populations and if the site is closed residents, including working families, those without cars and the elderly, will have to travel a long way to the nearest site in Buxton.
The council’s Cabinet Member for Net Zero and Environment, Cllr Carol Wood, claims the Glossop centre collects the lowest volume of waste out of all the council’s nine waste sites and that it is predominantly used by people from outside Derbyshire who do not pay council tax to the authority.
Derbyshire County Council has predicted a shortfall in its budget for the 2026-27 financial year of £37.8m which has led to the latest proposed savings measures or planned cuts being put forward to set a balanced budget and ensure the provision of essential services.
Its new overall saving proposals aim to deliver £22.4m of savings in 2026-27 to support meeting the forecast budget funding shortfall and it says the remaining shortfall will be made up from £2.5m of savings with changes to the way the council operates and with £12.9m to be saved from corporate budgets.
These saving plans could see the closure of the Glossop Household Waste Recycling Centre, a review of fee rates for home care, changes to the community support beds system in care homes to reduce costs, more technology to support adult social care, and a service redesign with a ‘transformation’ department and the removal of long-term vacancies across corporate services.
The council claims the Glossop tip collects the lowest volume of waste out of all of the nine household waste recycling centres that the council provides and it is the least used, and that the majority of people who use it are not from the county.
It also estimates that around seven out of ten visitors who use the site live outside of the county and it claims a £500,000 investment would be needed to make sure the site complies with modern requirements and safety regulations to stay open.
The council has also pointed out that most Derbyshire districts and boroughs operate with one waste site and the High Peak currently has two tips including the Glossop site and one in Buxton.
Cllr Isherwood, who represents Etherow, in the High Peak, said he could not support the proposed closure of the Glossop tip because he does not feel its use has been properly measured and he does not think the plan is justified or fair.
He argued that the question is not whether the council balances the books, it is how the books are balanced? And he added that ‘least used does not mean the least needed’.
Cllr Isherwood believes closing the Glossop tip will put pressure on other sites, will mean an increase in waste enforcement and more clean up costs.
He said: “We have not removed the burden. We have moved it around and created a false economy.”
Cllr Isherwood urged the council: “Do not close the site on estimates and call it prudence because when it’s closed it is not a minor tweak. I am not asking the impossible. I am asking for the reasonable. Withdraw it from the budget.”
Green Party Group Leader, Cllr Gez Kinsella, also argued if the tip closed it will leave residents having to travel an hour to Buxton and he questioned the council’s claims that the site is being used mainly by outsiders because it operates a vehicle Automatic Number Plate Recognition System for registered Derbyshire users and to deter outsiders.
He said: “This is a frontline service. This is really important to the environment and to the people in that area. I myself have worked out how long it takes to go to that tip and it’s about an hour’s drive.”
Conservative Group Leader, Cllr Alex Dale, said that if the council was not willing to use its recently allocated £2.6m of Government funding to reduce a council tax increase of 4.9per cent then the money should be used to keep the Glossop tip open.
He also questioned the council’s calculations about the site’s use and stressed that even if it is used by people from outside the county it is also very much used by Derbyshire residents.
Fellow Conservative Cllr Nigel Gourlay said: “If this site closes many residents will face a round-trip of well over an hour to use the next facility in my district.”
Cllr Gourlay, who stressed evidence concerning the tip needs to be clear, argued that removing the site could create a ‘real barrier’ and this could change behaviour with consequences including greater costs for enforcement, environmental damage and in community frustration.
Liberal Democrat Cllr Tom Snowdon also questioned the council’s findings on the number of residents using the tip from outside Derbyshire.
And Labour Cllr Damien Greenhalgh said the High Peak has two tips because the rural area has particular problems for journey times and he described the closure of Glossop tip as a bad idea.
Cllr Wood told the meeting that a consultation is planned to consider the proposal and no decision is expected on the tip’s future until June to allow for a full evaluation.
She argued the council has estimated that as many as seven out of ten people who use the tip are not from Derbyshire based on the experience of staff.
Opposition councillors have previously raised concerns the proposed Glossop closure may trigger an increase in fly-tipping.
But Cllr Wood told the meeting: “The facts are that fly-tipping is undertaken by commercial trade people.
“There is a lot of crime in commercial waste and studies show that restrictions and times at household waste facilities do not increase fly-tipping by domestic users.”
Cllr Wood has argued a study based on using its Northwood site as a ‘control’ baseline example helped establish figures from which the council has been able to infer that Glossop was predominantly used by non-Derbyshire residents who do not pay council tax to the county.
Council Leader, Cllr Alan Graves, told the council meeting: “We have not made a decision to close it. It’s part of budget proposals and as Cllr Wood pointed out we are consulting on it and what I would encourage you to do is to engage in that consultation.”
Derbyshire County Council has previously stated that if the proposed savings and efficiencies do not progress then alternative savings will need to be found by services in order to meet a legal obligation to set a balanced budget.
The council’s budget plan has also not ruled out job cuts but it states that it will seek to avoid this where possible through other savings within departments with vacancy controls, redeployment and ‘voluntary release’.
Cllr John Lawson said: “There is a process we are dealing with. It’s a proposed saving that has gone into our budget. It’s one that requires by law consultation with the public and once we have all the relevant data – not just estimates, but real data – then we will make a final decision.
“I implore all the public, not just the people in Glossop and Derbyshire, to engage with that process.”
The council voted by a majority against Cllr Wharmby’s amendment to save the tip from saving plans as the authority opted to keep the proposed closure of Glossop waste site in its overall approved Revenue Budget for the 2026-27 financial year.
Reform Cllr Stephen Reed said that further evidence is being gathered and more reports are being read for the council to make an informed final decision on the waste site’s future at a later time.
Derbyshire County Council currently runs nine waste recycling centres across the county for Derbyshire residents including Chesterfield, Bolsover, Loscoe, Northwood at Darley Dale, Ilkeston, Glossop, Ashbourne, Bretby and Waterswallows, at Buxton.
The council’s Conservative administration reduced opening hours in 2024 at eight of its nine waste sites, excluding Buxton, and introduced charges for tyre and asbestos disposals as well as a vehicle ANPR system to deter outsiders to save £500,000 as part of efforts to overcome a multi-million pound budget deficit.