Council rules on controversial plan to site 20m telecoms mast in north Derbyshire town

Controversial plans for a slimline telecoms mast in a north Derbyshire town have been refused prior approval for the siting and appearance.

The proposal for the 20m monopole on land at the junction of Green Lane and Stonelow Road, Dronfield was ruled by North East Derbyshire Council to represent an incongruous feature within the street scene because of the scale and utilitarian design. The mast would be sited in close proximity to residential properties whose current views do not include other tall features and therefore the mast would be likely to represent an overbearing and oppressive impact on these homes. Additionally, the reduction in width of the pavement arising from the installation of fixed infrastructure would result in an unacceptable impact on pedestrian accessibility.

An officer’s report to the planning authority included objections from councillors who represent the ward. Among them was Cllr Smith who commented: “We understand that this proposal may be for permitted development but we object to this particular site being used. This site for a 20 metre monopole and ancillary equipment is on the corner of Green Lane and Stonelow Road where hundreds of school students, staff and the public walk past every day. At the nearby school of Dronfield Henry Fanshawe there are approximately 1800 students and staff. The shops on the Greendale shopping precinct are a magnet for people at lunchtime and after school. Also, this is a very busy road and a major bus route. Nearby to this site is a retail shop called Stone the Crows and this building already has many telecoms aerials erected on their roof. Also, further up Green Lane there is a relatively new large monopole. We are agreed locally that this is a total unsuitable site for a 20m monopole."

Cllr Spooner said: “The height is excessive and overbearing. Have less impactful and visual alternative locations been sufficiently explored and has the applicant clearly demonstrated without doubt that this is the most suitable

Application site at the junction of Stonelow Road and Green Lane in Dronfield.placeholder image
Application site at the junction of Stonelow Road and Green Lane in Dronfield.

and appropriate?”

Dronfield Town Council listed several objections which included ineffective community engagement because many residents and the local county councillor had not been informed or consulted prior to this application. According to letters of objection to the district council, the site notice was put up 10 days after the prior approval was registered and only four properties were consulted by letter.

The officer’s report said that the closest residential property to the application site is 40 Green Lane. The proposed mast would be visible from the garden serving this dwelling and also visible from windows in 19 and 21 Green Lane.

The proposed monopole and cabinets, which would be set into the existing tarmac footpath, would be more than three times the height of lamp-posts which are 6.3m.

Upgrading the rooftop site at Stone the Crows, which currently serves the area, is not an option “due to ICNIRP issue with the new equipment and the three storey building to the east” states the officer’s report. “22 alternative sites have been investigated for potential siting of the proposals, however these have been discounted for various technical, structural and other reasons. The proposed location would address the gap in coverage and provide a service for both local residents, businesses and those moving through the area.”

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice