Column: It's no laughing matter if we let power control which jokes are told

The Green Party has been running diversity training sessions in which members were told that if they overhear a joke they find uncomfortable, they should record what happened, including dates, times and locations, and be prepared to pass this information to party officials, says comedian and writer Steve N Allen.

In comedy, snitches aren’t in stitches.

Guest columnist Steve N Allen is a writer and comedian.placeholder image
Guest columnist Steve N Allen is a writer and comedian.

The interesting angle is the training says you should do this even if no-one involved was offended. The example they give is about someone telling a joke about someone being a Polish person. My other half is Polish, so I feel very targeted.

Their advice is that you should report the joke even if the Polish person is laughing and even if they were the one telling the joke. If someone makes a joke about themselves and no-one there is offended, who are we protecting? The eavesdroppers?

"Comedy has always been one of the things that tells power when it is being ridiculous"placeholder image
"Comedy has always been one of the things that tells power when it is being ridiculous"

This was training material that was seen by a newspaper. The trainer giving the session said, “I’m not here to be the joke police.” She said this while explaining how to police jokes.

Which is almost the joke, but I’m not sure if I’m allowed to do it.

There was another exercise to fix what they call affinity bias. Members were asked to write down the names of their five closest friends and tick if they shared their ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion or level of education. They didn’t ask if all our friends are politically aligned with you. Funny that. But not funny in a joke way.

People were asked to consider forming more diverse friendships. I have questions about the audit. How do you determine the ethnicity of your friends without making the whole thing incredibly awkward?

Do you produce a clipboard in the pub? I presume you say, “Before we get the drinks in, I need to know where your grandparents were from.”

And what happens if you discover that all five of your closest friends are suspiciously similar to you? Do you have to get new ones? I’m lucky, I’m from a working-class background and my partner is middle-class and ethnically Polish. And I’m a married man, so I don’t have any other friends. So that’s 100 per cent of my friend circle I don’t have much affinity with.

The Green Party says these are standard equality, diversity and inclusion activities designed to spark discussion about creating safe and welcoming spaces. But comedy has always been one of the things that tells power when it is being ridiculous. If we let power control which jokes can be told, that important feedback loop will be lost.

And that’s no laughing matter.

News you can trust since 1855
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice