Surge in coronavirus fines issued by Derbyshire police
More than 700 fines were issued by police in Derbyshire for breaches of Covid-19 laws over Christmas and the start of this year, figures show – almost three-quarters of all fines issued since the start of the pandemic.
But the approach by police has been called into question by MPs and peers who, in calling for a review, have described the fines as "muddled, discriminatory and unfair".
In a report, the Joint Committee on Human Rights said the Coronavirus Act had been misunderstood and wrongly applied by police.
Figures published by the National Police Chiefs' Council reveal a total of 1,048 fixed penalty notices were recorded as being issued by Derbyshire Constabulary between March 27 last year and April 18 this year.
They include 747 fines after December 20 – 71% of the total handed out by officers since the pandemic began.
However, the figures do show a slowing down in the number of fines issued over more recent weeks, with 298 given out by officers between March 14 and April 18.
Across England and Wales, police forces have issued 110,322 fixed penalty notices under the Health Protection (Coronavirus, Restrictions) Regulations.
However, the JCHR has criticised the system, raising concerns over the validity of the fines, the inadequacy of the review and appeal process and the size of penalties.
The maximum penalty for the breach of a Covid-19 law is £10,000.
Harriet Harman, JCHR chair, said: “The police have had a difficult job in policing the pandemic.
"We hope that their initial approach – to engage, explain and encourage before issuing fixed penalty notices – will continue.
"However, since January there have been greater numbers of FPNs as police move more quickly to enforcement action."
Coronavirus rules have changed at least 65 times since March 2020, providing “obvious challenges for police”, according to a report by the JCHR.
Of the fines in Derbyshire from March 27 last year to April 18 this year there were 23 for failing to wear a face covering when required, and five for breaching international travel rules.
There were also six for breaking business regulations and two for holding a gathering of more than 30 people.
They also included one fine was given for breaching self-isolation regulations.
The remaining fines were for offences not specifically provided by the NPCC at a force level.
The figures cover the end of the tier system, which saw stricter restrictions on hospitality businesses and a banning of travel between areas with different tiers..
Since then, a lifting of restrictions saw schools reopen in March followed by a rule allowing groups of up to six of two households to meet outside.
In April, measures were further relaxed with the opening of retail, public buildings and holiday lets.
The NPCC said it would be considering the recommendations in the JCHR report.
Assistant Chief Constable Owen Weatherill, NPCC lead for the police response to Covid-19, said: “Policing has quickly adapted to changes in these unprecedented circumstances.
"When new regulations are issued, we ensure officers have additional guidance on the legislation and we continue to support them to reduce any errors in its application.
"We do recognise however that we have not got it right in every circumstance."
He added the NPCC would work with its criminal justice partners to rectify any errors.